2020s unlikely to be a rerun of the 1930s and 2000s

We anticipate that US equities will outperform long-dated Treasuries over the next ten years, even though the valuation of the stock market is even higher now than it was at the beginning of the 1930s and approaching its level at the outset of the 2000s – the only two decades in the past 100 years when US equities underperformed. The underperformance of US equities vis-à-vis long-dated Treasuries in the 1930s and 2000s (see Chart 1) followed the bursting of bubbles in the stock market. We don’t think we are in the latter stages of another bubble now, though, despite Shiller’s cyclically adjusted price earnings ratio (CAPE) for the S&P 500/ Composite being above its level on the eve of the Great Crash and only ever being exceeded in the final stages of the dotcom boom. A key reason is that the valuation of the stock market does not look stretched relative to that of the bond market. Some other hallmarks of stock market bubbles also appear to us to be missing, such as high leverage and major financial imbalances. The upshot is that, over the next ten years or so, we project that the real returns from US equities will still be positive (albeit less so than in the 2010s and 2020), whereas we forecast that those from long-dated Treasuries will be negative against a backdrop of a slow rise in nominal yields and inflation.
John Higgins Chief Markets Economist
Continue reading

More from The Long Run

Long Run Returns Monitor

Long Run Returns Monitor (Nov.)

Our monthly Long Run Returns Monitor provides our updated long-term projected returns for major asset classes, as well as a summary of the macroeconomic forecasts which underpin them. All projections in this publication are as of 23rd November 2021. A more detailed explanation of our views can be found in our annual Long Run Economic Outlook and Long Run Asset Allocation Outlook.

25 November 2021

Long Run Update

COP26 a small step forward but much left to do

COP26 has progressed efforts to fight climate change, but there is still a significant gap between pledges and actual policies. Unless action ramps up this decade, countries may face a choice between accepting the costs of greater global warming or a rapid, and potentially disorderly, transition to a greener economy.

16 November 2021

Long Run Update

COP26 unlikely to alter economic outlook

The UN’s annual climate change conference, COP26, has the potential to be an important milestone but it is just one step along the path required to limit global warming. Accordingly, it will not on its own stop climate change from clouding the long-run economic outlook for many emerging markets in particular.

2 November 2021

More from John Higgins

Asset Allocation Update

What’s behind renewed US equity outperformance?

It has become harder to make the case that the stock market in the US will fare worse than those in the rest of the developed world, now that the “rotation” trade has fizzled out. Nonetheless, we still think there are other reasons to expect the relentless outperformance of US equities to end.

7 July 2021

Asset Allocation Update

Would US equities beat Treasuries if inflation surged?

The received wisdom is that inflation is worse for government bonds than for equities. Yet the S&P 500 has fared worse than 10-year Treasuries in a couple of periods of high inflation in the US since the 1960s.

1 July 2021

Capital Daily

Consumer confidence and the US stock market

We do not think that the surge in the Conference Board’s index of consumer confidence in June is a reason to be positive about the outlook for the US stock market.

30 June 2021
↑ Back to top