UI expansion to cushion blow from layoffs

  • The significant increase in unemployment insurance payments included in the recent fiscal package means that many claimants could end up being paid close to what they previously earned. This suggests that the unprecedented wave of layoffs in recent weeks may not prove as damaging as it first seems.
  • The fiscal measures announced in the US have not gone as far as some European countries in attempting to safeguard jobs. While more European countries have introduced wage subsidy schemes modelled on the success of Germany’s Kurzarbeit program, the $2trn CARES Act only included a modest $350bn in loans for small business, forgivable if they maintain payrolls, which were only available from last Friday. Although the latter now looks set to be expanded, it failed to prevent millions of job losses in recent weeks.
  • Nonetheless, the recent fiscal package did provide significant direct support for workers which, alongside the $1,200 cheques sent out to most taxpayers, included a major expansion of Federal unemployment insurance (UI). Eligibility has been broadened to include the self-employed, part-time and gig workers, the maximum benefit period has been extended by 13 weeks, or 50% in most states, and, most significantly, a fixed $600 supplement will be added to all weekly payments for the next four months.
  • As a result, the average weekly payment for some new UI claimants could be higher than their previous earnings. With the average payment standing at $370 in 2019, the new Federal supplement should bring the total payment to nearly $1000 – higher than average weekly pay for private sector workers and more than double the typical earnings of those in the hardest-hit leisure & hospitality sector. (See Chart 1.) Admittedly, the reality is more complicated as states calculate benefit amounts as a share of previous earnings, so the lowest paid workers also receive the smallest benefit payments. The average weekly earnings data also may not fully capture tips earned by hospitality workers or other benefits. But the new $600 Federal payment alone still exceeds average earnings in leisure & hospitality by almost 50%.
  • This may in turn be part of the reason why jobless claims have soared so rapidly in recent weeks. Workers may be more accepting of temporary furloughs if they stand to lose little income, and several major retailers have cited the new provisions when announcing layoffs. The upshot is that while the unemployment rate has probably already surpassed its post-GFC peak and could rise even higher over the coming months, the damage in terms of lost income may end up being less severe. (See Chart 2.)
  • Admittedly, the US system is far from perfect. There are widespread reports of UI claims being delayed or wrongly rejected due to dilapidated state IT systems. Some workers whose hours have been cut may still earn too much to qualify for UI and will therefore lose out, with the work-sharing schemes available in some states (which the CARES act commits to funding) less developed than those in Europe. Most importantly, by encouraging layoffs, the UI expansion could make it harder to maintain the relationship between furloughed workers and their employers, hampering the eventual recovery. The latter could become a particular problem once the initial four months of $600 weekly payments ends. Overall, however, the speed and strength of the economic recovery will depend most on how quickly containment measures can be safely lifted, which in turn may hinge on how quickly testing can be ramped up.

Chart 1: Average Weekly Earnings by Industry ($)

Chart 2: Unemployment Rate (%)

Sources: Refinitiv, DoL, Capital Economics

Andrew Hunter, Senior US Economist, andrew.hunter@capitaleconomics.com

Andrew Hunter Senior US Economist
Continue reading

More from US

US Economics Weekly

Powell gets the nod; GDP growth rebounding

The announcement on Monday morning that President Biden would nominate Jerome Powell for a second term as Fed Chair was largely as expected, although the unexplained delays in making it official may have persuaded some in the markets that Biden was leaning toward picking Lael Brainard instead. As far as monetary policy goes, Powell and Brainard hold very similar, largely dovish, views. Elsewhere, as a result of the flurry of economic data releases ahead of the Thanksgiving Holiday we have raised our fourth-quarter GDP growth forecast to 6.5% annualised, from 4.0%.

24 November 2021

US Data Response

Durable Goods, Adv. Trade (Oct.), GDP (Q3 2nd Est.)

The 0.5% fall in durable goods orders was not as bad as it looked, given that it was entirely due to a fall in volatile aircraft orders. But the bigger news this morning was the huge 10.7% m/m surge in exports in October, which is why we now estimate that GDP growth will accelerate from 2.1% annualised in the third quarter to more than 5% in the fourth, well above our previous forecast of a rise to 4%.

24 November 2021

US Employment Report Preview

Slowdown ahead

We expect non-farm payrolls to have risen by a solid 500,000 in November, but the growing risk of a winter COVID wave and a dwindling supply of available workers look set to weigh on employment growth soon.

24 November 2021

More from Andrew Hunter

US Data Response

Industrial Production (May)

The 0.8% m/m rise in industrial production in May, driven by a 0.9% gain in manufacturing output, suggests that some of the shortages holding back production in recent months could have eased. But manufacturing output is still slightly below its pre-pandemic peak and continues to lag well behind the earlier resurgence in goods demand.

15 June 2021

US Data Response

Consumer Prices (May)

The further jump in core CPI inflation to a 28-year high of 3.8% in May, from 3.0%, was again driven by the same handful of categories most directly affect by the lifting of virus restrictions. But there were also signs of emerging inflationary pressures in other sectors, including housing costs and restaurant prices, which suggests that not all the current upward pressure on inflation will prove transitory.

10 June 2021

US Fed Watch

Talking about talking about tapering

Fed officials may finally begin ‘talking about talking about’ tapering their asset purchases at next week’s FOMC meeting. But with recent data leaving the economy still some way from making “substantial further progress” towards the Fed’s full employment goal, we suspect that taper won’t begin until early next year.

9 June 2021
↑ Back to top