Lumber prices to be cut down to size

  • Even though we expect lumber demand to hold up well for some time, we still think that a rebound in supply will lead to a sharp fall in the price of US lumber over the next eighteen months.
  • The price of US lumber (CME random lengths) has skyrocketed from $875 per 1,000 broad feet at the beginning of the year to just over $1,325, which is more than four times its 2010-20 average of $325. Demand from the US housing sector has boomed in the past year. Housing starts have picked up recently (in large part owing to low existing inventories) and some households have used accumulated savings and stimulus payments associated with the COVID-19 pandemic to renovate and expand their houses. Meanwhile, regional supply issues including a shortage of truck drivers, virus-related restrictions on social interaction, and the ongoing outbreak of mountain pine beetle in Canada have also supported the price.
  • We think that demand for lumber will remain elevated over the next eighteen months. The inventory of existing homes for sale is at a record low and will remain so for some time, which should continue to bolster house prices, homebuilder confidence and, in turn, the construction of lumber-intensive single-family units. (See Chart 1 and our US Housing Market Outlook.) Moreover, we suspect that even more households will renovate and expand their properties to help facilitate homeworking, although the high price of lumber might delay some refurbishment plans.
  • Despite our positive outlook for demand, we still expect the price of lumber to decline sharply by end-2022 for two key reasons. First, we expect domestic production to soar. For one, the progressive easing of quarantine measures should allow lumber mills to return to full capacity fairly soon. In addition, the recent pick-up in hiring and higher trucker pay are likely to alleviate the current shortage of truck drivers, which should help resolve some of the logistical constraints.
  • Second, US lumber imports have increased in recent months, and they could rise further, spurred on by the high domestic price but also because of an appreciation in the value of the US dollar. (See our Global Markets Update.) What’s more, the Biden administration could (temporarily) cut tariffs on imports from Canada (the top lumber exporter to the US), which would provide a further boost to imports. (See Chart 2.) The Trump administration reduced lumber tariffs to an average of 9%, from 20%, in December 2020 in part to help the domestic homebuilding sector and there is even more impetus to cut tariffs now that the price of lumber is at a record high.
  • All told, we forecast that the price of US lumber will plummet to $600 and $550 per 1,000 broad feet by end-2021 and end-2022, respectively, as domestic supply surges and imports remain strong.

Chart 1: NAHB Homebuilder Confidence & US Single-Family Housing Starts

Chart 2: Lumber Railcars from Canada

Sources: Refinitiv, Capital Economics

Sources: Refinitiv, Capital Economics


Samuel Burman, Assistant Commodities Economist, samuel.burman@capitaleconomics.com

Download
Save
Samuel Burman Assistant Commodities Economist
Continue reading

More from Commodities

Commodities Weekly Wrap

Three key developments to keep an eye on

Most commodity prices ground higher this week. And, stepping back, we think events this week highlight three key themes to watch in the months ahead. First, natural gas prices show no sign of easing back, and are likely to remain high until early next year. Prices continued to surge this week on the back of ongoing supply disruptions and unseasonably strong demand in Asia. And, even if both these tailwinds fade, a rebuilding of stocks from their current lows should continue to support prices. Second, the growing divergence between industrial metals prices and underlying demand could set the stage for a sharp correction before the year is out. Despite the weaker-than-expected activity data out of China, industrial metals prices were a mixed bag this week. Nonetheless, they still remain close to multi-year highs. And finally, calls for OPEC+ to fully unwind its output cut before the end of next year (as is currently planned) look set to grow louder. The Biden Administration has already called for this and China has announced crude sales from its strategic reserve in an apparent bid to stem the rise in prices. The main event for commodity markets next week will be the Fed’s FOMC meeting (Tuesday/Wednesday). While we expect the Fed will fall short of formally announcing tapering QE, they may prepare the ground for it at the meeting. A repeat of the June meeting’s hawkish surprise could set the tone and drive a dollar rally, which would weigh on the prices of all commodities but particularly on some of the precious metals, which have tracked the dollar closely this year.

17 September 2021

Commodities Weekly Wrap

More of the same

Commodity markets have been relatively quiet over the last few weeks, with many prices trading in a narrow range. There are a few exceptions, most notably the prices of natural gas and coal, which have soared on the back of surging power demand and constrained supply. In contrast, oil has continued to hover around $70 per barrel, as concerns about demand prevent price gains and as OPEC+ supply restraint acts as a floor under prices. We think next week could be a bit directionless again. China is set to publish its monthly activity and spending data on Wednesday, which we expect to show further weakness. So far, commodity prices have been surprisingly sanguine about the economic downturn in China. But there are now clear signs that growth in the US and UK economies is also slowing, which underpins our view that most commodity prices will be falling as we move into 2022. CE Spotlight 2021: The Rebirth Of Inflation? We’re holding a week of online events from 27th September to accompany our special research series. Event details and registration here.

10 September 2021

Commodities Update

Shift in spending could hit demand for commodities

Although world trade volumes are likely to hold up for a while yet, a reversal of some of the shift in spending patterns caused by the pandemic is likely to weigh on commodity demand. This is another reason to expect most commodity prices to end the year lower.

8 September 2021

More from Samuel Burman

Energy Update

OPEC impasse: what next?

The failure of OPEC+ to agree to new production quotas has created considerable uncertainty about the group’s oil production going forward. In this Update, we lay out three possible scenarios for OPEC+ output in the coming months and what they would mean for oil prices.

6 July 2021

Energy Update

Rising production to take the sizzle out of Henry Hub

Strong industrial demand and constrained domestic supply will support US natural gas prices throughout the remainder of this year. However, we expect that the average price will fall in 2022 in large part because of higher production.

28 June 2021

Commodities Update

Timberrrrrrrr...

Although we remain optimistic about the near-term demand outlook, we think that the price of US lumber will fall further in the coming months as domestic supply continues to revive.

23 June 2021
↑ Back to top